If there’s one thing New York City does right (and trust me, it does a lot right), it’s pizza. Whether you’re walking through Brooklyn, hanging out in the Bronx, or wandering the streets of Manhattan, you’re never too far from a slice of cheesy heaven. But not all pizza is created equal. Some slices? They’re just different. So, if you’re a pizza lover, or even just a hungry traveler, these are the spots that are worth the trip—every single bite.
Joe’s Pizza – A Classic You Can’t Miss
Ever had a slice that feels like a warm hug? That’s Joe’s Pizza. This place has been around since the ’70s and is one of the most famous pizza joints in NYC. Their slices are thin, crispy, and perfectly cheesy. You can grab one, fold it in half (New York-style, of course), and just enjoy the simple perfection. It’s not fancy, but that’s the magic of it. No gimmicks, just great pizza.
Lucali – A Slice of Heaven in Brooklyn
Tucked away in Carroll Gardens, Lucali is the kind of spot that makes you feel like you’ve discovered a hidden gem. The vibe? Super cozy. The pizza? Life-changing. It’s all about the thin crust, fresh tomato sauce, and top-notch ingredients. Oh, and don’t be surprised if you see a celeb or two while you’re there. People love this place—for good reason.
Prince Street Pizza – Pepperoni Like You’ve Never Seen
If you’ve seen thick, square slices overflowing with pepperoni on Instagram, chances are it’s from Prince Street Pizza. Their Spicy Pepperoni Sicilian slice is a game-changer. It’s cheesy, it’s spicy, it’s crunchy on the bottom, and those little pepperoni cups? Total flavor bombs. It’s a must-try for anyone who thinks they’ve already had the best pizza. Spoiler alert: you haven’t.
Di Fara Pizza – Legendary for a Reason
This one’s for the real pizza fans. Di Fara in Brooklyn is legendary. The owner, Dom DeMarco, made every pie himself for decades. And while he’s passed on, his family keeps the legacy alive. Every slice is made with love, fresh ingredients, and that old-school Italian touch. Be ready to wait a bit—it’s super popular—but that first bite will make it all worth it.
Roberta’s – The Cool Kid of the Pizza World
Roberta’s is where pizza meets creativity. Located in Bushwick, Brooklyn, this spot is fun, artsy, and full of flavor. Their wood-fired pizzas are packed with unique toppings you won’t find anywhere else—like honey, spicy soppressata, or even egg. It’s pizza, but with a twist. If you like trying new things, this place is your jam.
Patsy’s – Old-School Charm, Timeless Taste
Patsy’s in East Harlem has been around since 1933. Yeah, it’s that old—and still rocking. Their coal oven gives the pizza a slightly smoky flavor that’s out of this world. The crust is thin and crispy, and the sauce is rich and tangy. It’s simple, but every bite tells a story. If you’re into history and good food, you’ll love it here.
L&B Spumoni Gardens – For the Love of Sicilian
Looking for a thick, fluffy, cheesy slice? Head to L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn. Their Sicilian-style pizza is famous for a reason. It’s not your usual slice—the sauce is on top of the cheese, which sounds crazy until you try it. The crust is soft and pillowy, the sauce is sweet, and it’s all kinds of delicious. Oh, and get some spumoni ice cream while you’re at it. Thank me later.
Conclusion
New York pizza isn’t just food—it’s a full-on experience. From thin-crust classics to thick Sicilian slices, there’s something here for every pizza lover. These seven spots are more than just places to eat—they’re destinations. Whether you’re a tourist or a local, these pizzerias are totally worth the trip. So go ahead, grab a slice (or three), and taste what makes New York pizza so special.
FAQs
What’s the best time to visit these pizza places?
Midday or early evening is best to avoid long lines, especially on weekends.
Do these spots offer vegetarian options?
Absolutely! Most have veggie-friendly slices with fresh toppings.
Can I get gluten-free pizza at these places?
Some, like Roberta’s, offer gluten-free options. It’s best to call ahead and check.
Are these pizzerias kid-friendly?
Totally! Pizza is loved by everyone, and most places are casual and great for families.
How much does a slice cost in New York?
Prices vary, but you can expect to pay anywhere from $3 to $6 per slice depending on the spot.
